Wednesday, August 19, 2009

Erick Erickson defends Sarah, scolds Heritage

RedState.com's  Erick Erickson, our Managing Editor when Warner and I were regular contributors there, has called out an iconic conservative institution:
As if on cue, Stuart Butler from the Heritage Foundation, has decided to take issue with Sarah Palin’s use of the phrase “death panels.” Butler is defending Ezekiel Emanuel, Rahm’s brother, who has written that we need not guarantee healthcare benefits to people with dementia because they cannot be full participants in the body politic.

Emanuel’s actual quote: “[S]ervices provided to individuals who are irreversibly prevented from being or becoming participating citizens [in the body politic] are not basic and should not be guaranteed. An obvious example is not guaranteeing health services to patients with dementia.”

Butler is defending Emanuel and attacking Palin at the precise moment the Democrats are in full scale retreat on the issue because of Palin’s offensive. Sigh. These guys have the political instincts of amoebas.
Erick points to what appears to be a significant softening of Heritage's once-strong Federalist tradition:
The Heritage Foundation, which played a vital part in building conservative support for Romneycare in Massachusetts, is setting the stage for Republican capitulation on healthcare. This is the second time in less than a year that Heritage will have been instrumental in organizing a conservative collapse in opposition to big government. The first time was when Heritage gave conservatives cover to support TARP, calling it “vital and acceptable.”

Now with healthcare, because Heritage is trying to be “helpful”, confusion is starting to crop up among Republicans in Congress at a very critical time in the healthcare debate. Capitulation and compromise are now on the table using a bastardized version of a Heritage proposal.
It's sad to see Heritage playing into the Democrats hands. Like Erick says, the smart people there should have seen this coming.

- JP

3 comments:

  1. i will cancel my membership in the heritage foundation and tell them why!

    ReplyDelete
  2. They've been bought by Romney. Looks like the entire conservative establishment has been bought out by Romney.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Not a fan of Erickson's handling of Palin in general at Red State and so deleted it out of my must-reads. I appreciate his intellectual honesty to briefly mention her and call Heritage out for dividing the troops.

    But I think he himself is too much a politics-as-usual person to see Palin's potential. And her resignation just gave him the fodder he needed to dismiss her politically.

    Glad to see he doesn't have full-blown PDS, however, and is able to see how calling her out divides the party and the message against govt health care.

    ReplyDelete