*
Get the pity party violin music warmed up because Ezra Klein and Dave Weigel are whining that Sarah Palin has forced them, the press, into a "submissive role" because she is so mean to them.
Klein favorably cites the analysis of Weigel who whined that the "Palin problem" has "put the press in a submissive position."
The problem is that Palin has put the political press in a submissive position, one in which the only information it prints about her comes from prepared statements or from Q&As with friendly interviewers. This isn’t something most politicians get away with, or would be allowed to get away with. But Palin has leveraged her celebrity — her ability to get ratings, the ardor of her fans and the bitterness of her critics — to win a truly unique relationship with the press. She is allowed to shape the public debate without actually engaging in it.Oh, boo hoo. Now we have to feel sorry for the press over the feeling that mean 'ol Sarah Palin has been successful in leading them by the nose?
Of course, this ignores all the hate that the press has spread about Palin, it ignores all the fake "news" they, themselves have spread, stories filled with lies, half-truths and insults posing as news. It ignores the many Trig-isn't-hers stories the press spread, the false story of Palin's book banning, and…. well, I can name a hundred fake stories that the press has spread about Palin. And they have ALL been stories that Palin was in no way controlling or trying to herself spread.
So, right off the top, Klein by way of Weigel is lying by only focusing on her late public persona and not focusing on their culpability for spreading lies for months before she finally had enough of it and began to more carefully control her public utterances.
However, Klein's whining about Palin aside, he does have a good point about the failure of the press to place the news in the greater context of the reality of the world even as he papers over the fact that newspapers are, indeed, working hard to pass lies as news.
For one thing, newspapers work very hard to report things that are true, but they are less concerned with whether the overall impression from their reporting is a true impression. Shark attacks, for instance, happen very rarely. But if you report excitedly on every shark attack that happens, people will think they happen quite a bit.Klein is wrong that the newspapers "work very hard to report things that are true." The fact is most newspapers work very hard to spin the truth to a left-wing perspective in order to further extremist, left-wing ideas. However, Klein is right that newspapers fail to report the greater context of the facts. They do it on purpose, though, in order for the spin to work better.
For instance, the "news" has been floating the idea that the recent unemployment numbers did not grow and newspapers have marked that as an "unexpected drop" in unemployment as if it's all good news. However, few papers have bothered to mention that this has been a tiny drop in rates during a steady years-long rise in unemployment. The impression is that good news was had, but the facts prove otherwise. Context is ignored in order to make Obama seem a success.
Anyway, it is amusing to see the Old Media crying that Palin is messing with them like this. An unexpected Christmas present if there ever was one.
- WTH
Warner Todd Huston is editor of Publius' Forum and a regular contributor to Texas for Sarah Palin.
The media has been in attack mode on Sarah Palin from the very first moments that John McCain announced that she was his running mate in Ohio. Sarah has every right to treat the media with distrust and opposition, because they sure as hell haven't been fair and balanced towards her in which to warrant her respect.
ReplyDeleteKlein writes, "One of the jobs the media does[sic] is deciding what true things count as news and what true things do not count as news." In simpler words, the media act as gatekeepers. The bottom line is that Klein is upset that the gatekeepers can no longer control the message that they want America to hear.
ReplyDeletedessert surivivor "The bottom line is that Klein is upset that the gatekeepers can no longer control the message that they want America to hear."
ReplyDeleteExactly, you know it must kill the media knowing that Sarah Palin can impact any issue just by typing on facebook. She talked about "bypassing the "filter" of the mainstream media". Between using facebook and twitter, she's found that balance in which to do so. By her speaking in her own words, she has increased her approval numbers among the American people who thought negatively of her. She accomplished this without the support of the media. When Sarah starts to openly go after Obama and liberals next year, hear message is going to resonate with people who do feel disenfranchised thanks to Obama, Reid and Pelosi. The media is going to have a very hard time trying to discredit Palin while trying to prop up and become the political spin doctors for Obama. The media has fired every bit of tabloid hear say gossip against Sarah, and they have nothing else nor nothing new to fire at her. The fascinating aspect to Sarah Palin is that the people who don't trust either political parties trust Sarah Palin. Sarah Palin is the only political figure I can think of that is so connected with the values and thoughts of mainstream Americans.