Sarahy Palin was right: Herds rebound under predator control

The Alaska Department of Fish and Game has released its 2008-2009 predation management summary showing that moose and caribou herds in six predator control areas have increased:

The agency points to two areas in particular as examples of where the program is showing strong results: the Nelchina Basin area and the southern Alaska Peninsula.

The program is getting substantive results in the McGrath area, where it began in December 2003. Last winter and spring, 28 wolves were killed in the McGrath area. Nineteen were taken under the program and nine were hunted and trapped.

The agency said the moose population there has grown from 2,774 in 2004 to an estimated 5,500 moose now. The goal is to reach 6,000 to 8,000 moose.

Former governor Sarah Palin was targeted by animal rights activist groups for continuing the program, which was initiated by her predecessor, Gov. Frank Murkowski. During the fall 2008 presidential contest, the Defenders of Wildlife Action Fund sponsored an advertising campaign against then-Governor Palin, the GOP vice-presidential candidate, for expanding the program. Featuring actor Ashley Judd, the ad portrayed Palin as a heartless enemy of lovable, furry wolves who promoted the practice of hunting down the animals from aircraft just for the fun of it. The predator control program allows private citizens who obtain the proper permits to shoot wolves from the air or conduct land-and-shoot hunting of wolves in six rural areas of the state.  

But Palin in fact expanded the predator control program to help rural and native Alaskans who depend on hunting caribou and moose to survive. Those Alaskans had complained that the herd numbers had decreased to the point where there wasn't enough game for them to hunt and feed their families. 

The problem is that wolves, and to a lesser extent bears, are such efficient hunters that they had decimated the herd numbers. Compounding the problem is the fact that wolves give birth to litters of usually four or more pups, while moose and caribou calves are almost exclusively the products of single births. That the herd populations have recovered in the areas where wolf hunting was allowed is a vindication of former Governor Palin's policies. 

Alaska is not the only state which has predator control issues. Last week a U.S. District Court Judge ruled that gray wolf hunts could continue in Idaho and Montana:

U.S. District Court Judge Donald Molloy says wildlife groups are failing to show "irreparable harm" from Montana and Idaho wolf hunts, so he will not block hunters from killing the predators.

On Wednesday, Molloy announced his ruling to allow the gray wolf hunts to continue in the Northern Rockies, the first organized wolf hunts in Idaho and Montana in decades.

The problem in the Northern Rockies is that the wolves are killing off the local elk population at an alarming rate. But farm animals are also the victims of the wolf packs, one of which recently killed 120 sheep in one night on a ranch near Dillon, MT.

Update: At Sweetness & Light, Steve Gilbert quotes a Salon piece by Mark Benjamin to illustrate just how wrong the watermelons* were on this issue as they used it to slam Sarah Palin. Think we'll be seeing a mea culpa from Benjamin or other wolf huggers anytime soon? Don't count on it.

*(Watermelons are green on the outside, pink on the inside) 

- JP

Newsweek tackles predator control in Alaska

The article, written by Amanda Coyne, is surprisingly almost balanced, or at least as balanced as we're likely to see from such a leftist media outlet as Newsweek.

There are a lot of facts that were not included in the piece. Wolves, giving birth to litters of four or five pups, for example, reproduce at a much higher rate than do moose and caribou, giving birth to mostly one calf at a time. That's why the predator control programs have to be a continuing process. There's more vital information missing, but I suspect the author was limited to a specific word count.

To Ms. Coyne's credit, she does point out that the predator control debate has been raging in Alaska "since long before Palin came onto the scene." She also provides opposing opinions in quotes from two Alaska Department of Fish and Game officials, one appointed by Gov. Palin and another by Democrat former governor Tony Knowles.

But overall, the article is not balanced because she also quotes a biologist for Defenders of Wildlife, the left wing group which run the infamous anti-Palin ads featuring actress Ashley Judd. No opinion from an opposing group is presented. One such organization is Defenders of Wild Food, which describes itself as "a national effort dedicated to educating people regarding the importance of wildlife to the culture and diet of Alaskans." These defenders also have an ad:



As the late, great Paul Harvey would say, "Now you know the rest of the story."
- JP